Panch Raatra
(1) Five nights
and five days.
Vatsar (a year) is 12 x 30 =
360 days and a civil year is with 5 or 6 extra days at the end. These
5-6 days and nights are called Pancha-raatra or Shadaha.
(2) A Hindu sect, perhaps as
ancient as 100AD, which believed in one God and emphasized the path of
devotion. Their deity was Vishnu who was also called as Naaraayan, Hari,
Vaasudev, and Krishn. This sect did not believe in sacrifice and torture
of the body to please God. In all these things it represented the best
of Hinduism as it evolved after the age of Upanishad. Later it got
corrupted by Taantrik doctrines and lost its flavor.
[Aangiras, p 209]
(3) Panch-Raatra
states that the personality of Jeev called Sankarshan has
emerged from Vaasudev, the supreme cause of all causes; Pradyumn, the
mind, has come from Sankarshan, and that Aniruddh, the ego, has come from
Pradyumn. But one cannot say that the living entity (Jeev) takes birth or
is created, for such a statement is against the injunction of the Ved. As
stated
in the Kath Upanishad (2.18), living entities, as individual spiritual
souls, can have neither birth nor death. All Vaidik literature declares
that the living entities are eternal. Therefore when it is said that
Sankarshan is Jeev, this indicates that He is the predominating Deity of
the living entities. Similarly, Pradyumn is the predominating Deity of the
mind, and Aniruddh is the predominating Deity of the ego.
"It has been said that Pradyumn, the mind, was produced from Sankarshan.
But if Sankarshan were a living entity, this could not be accepted,
because a living entity cannot be the cause of the mind. The Vaidik
injunctions state that everything, including life, mind and the senses
comes from the Supreme Personality of Godhead. It is impossible for the
mind to be produced by a living entity, for the Ved state that everything
comes from the Absolute Truth, the Supreme Lord.
"Sankarshan, Pradyumn and Aniruddh have all the potent features of the
absolute Personality of Godhead, according to the revealed scriptures,
which contain undeniable facts that no one can refute. Therefore these
members of the quadruple manifestation are never to be considered ordinary
living beings. Each of Them is a plenary expansion of the Absolute
Godhead, and thus each is identical with the Supreme Lord in knowledge,
opulence, energy, influence, prowess and potencies.
“The evidence of the Panch
Raatra (there are many) cannot be neglected. Only untrained
persons who have not genuinely studied the Panch Raatra think that the
Panch Raatra contradict the Shruti regarding the birth or beginning of the
living entity. In this connection, we must accept the verdict of Shree-mad
Bhaagavat, which says, "The absolute Personality of Godhead, who is known
as Vaasudev and who is very affectionate toward
His surrendered devotees, expands Himself in quadruple forms who are
subordinate to Him and at the same time identical with Him in all
respects." The Paushkar Sanhitaa states, "The scriptures that recommend
that Braahman worship the quadruple forms of the Supreme Personality of
Godhead are called Agam."
In all Vaishnav literature it is said that
worshiping these quadruple forms is as good as worshiping the Supreme
Personality of Godhead Vaasudev who in His different expansions, complete
in six opulence, can accept offerings from His devotees of the results of
their prescribed duties.
“Worshiping the expansions for pastimes, such as Nrasinh, Raam, Shesh and
Koorm, promotes one to the worship of the Sankarshan quadruple. From that
position one is raised to the platform of worshiping Vaasudev, the Supreme
Brahm. In the Paushkar Sanhitaa it is said, "If one fully worships
according to the regulative principles, one can attain the Supreme
Personality of Godhead, Vaasudev." It is to be accepted that Sankarshan,
Pradyumn and Aniruddh are as good as Lord Vaasudev, for they all have
inconceivable power and can accept transcendental forms like Vaasudev.
Sankarshan, Pradyumn and Aniruddh are never born, but they can manifest
themselves in various incarnations before the eyes of pure devotees. This
is the conclusion of all Vaidik literature.
“That the Lord can manifest Himself before His devotees by His
inconceivable power is not against the teaching of the Panch Raatra. Since
Sankarshan, Pradyumn and Aniruddh are, respectively, the predominating
Deities of all living entities, the total mind and the total ego, the
designation of Sankarshan, Pradyumn and Aniruddh as "Jeev", "mind" and
"ego" are never contradictory to the statements of the scriptures. These
terms identify these Deities, just as the terms "sky" and "light"
sometimes identify the Absolute Brahm.
The scriptures
completely deny the birth or production of the living
entity. In the Param Sanhitaa it is described that material nature, which
is used for others' purposes, is factually inert and always subject to
transformation. The field of material nature is the arena of the
activities of fruitive actors, and since the material field is externally
related with the Supreme Personality of Godhead, it is also eternal. In
every Sanhitaa, the Jeev (living entity) has been accepted as eternal, and
in the Panch Raatra the birth of the Jeev is completely denied. Anything
that is produced must also be annihilated. Therefore if we accept the
birth of the living entity, we also have to accept his annihilation. But
since the Vaidik literatures say that the living entity is eternal, one
should not think the living being to be produced at a certain time. In the
beginning of the Param Sanhitaa it is definitely stated that the face of
material nature is constantly changeable. Therefore "beginning,"
"annihilation" and all such terms are applicable only in the material nature.
In this connection the
commentary of Sridhar Svami on Shree-mad Bhaagavat (3.1.34) is very
helpful.
For a detailed refutation of Shankarachaarya's arguments attempting to
prove Sankarshan an ordinary living being, one may refer to Srimat
Sudarshanaachaarya's commentary on the "Shree Bhaashya", which is known as
the Shrut Prakaashikaa.
(Shree Chaitanya-Charitaamrit Aadi-leelaa, 5.41 purport by Srila Prabhupaad
Bhaktivedaant Swaamee Mahaaraaj)